A federal judge in Delaware has dismissed a class-action lawsuit brought against Google for bypassing Safari privacy settings.
U.S. District Judge Sue Robinson wrote that the companies had circumvented the browsers’ settings, allowing users’ personal information to be sold to ad companies. But the judge said that the plaintiffs couldn’t show that they suffered because the companies collected and sold their information.
Back in 2012, the FTC investigated claims that Google circumvented Safari’s ad-block settings in order to store cookies and deliver targeted ads to users. The company agreed to pay a $22.5 million fine to settle the case but denied it did anything improper.
“Google did not intercept contents as provided for by the Wiretap Act,” Robinson wrote. “While URLs may provide a description of the contents of a document, e.g., www.helpfordrunks.com, a URL is a location identifier and does not ‘concern the substance, purport, or meaning’ of an electronic communication.”
Robinson also found that the plaintiffs failed to “demonstrate that Google intercepted any ‘contents or meaning'” under California’s Invasion of Privacy Act or identify “any impairment of the performance or functioning of their computers.”